Added: Oct 12, 2008
From: exodia
Duration: 2:34
For all Gundam fans
Channel: Entertainment
Tags: gundam
Rating: 4.66 (664 ratings) Views: 460173' favoriteCount='1129 Comments: 973
Weltall8000 Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - I am saying that Shinn is a better pilot, which the events in the series support.The barking comment was directed at Ibwui, not you. Though, you've offered very little facts, or what facts you have mentioned, you've grossly misinterpreted.Unfortunately for you, Kira vs Athrun in Seed was a defeat for Kira. The MS are weapons, Athrun used his weapon to defeat Kira and his weapon. It's like a sword fight, Athrun stabbed Kira and left his sword in Kira's body. Kira survived, but lost the fight
songlessnightingale Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - sorry to barge in your gundam dispute but I have one final question. Whatever happened to the relationship with Miriallia and Dearka in GSD?
xIxJustxPwnedxYoux Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - now you're saying you didn't imply that battle into your opinion about shin being a better pilot. you're denying your previous comments from earlier and you don't even know it
Weltall8000 Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - Ok, then Ibwui, you accept that Kira was trying to kill Shinn.Shinn beats Kira in that fight. (Despite Kira's attempts on Shinn's life)Kira never goes on to beat Shinn.Now, where do you get from this, that Kira is better than Shinn?
Weltall8000 Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - If his battery had not run out, when he began firing his cannon, that wasn't going to rip Strike's cockpit apart? If he had battery, that's what would have happened. He actually didn't have enough power, so he did the next best thing, he self detonated the Aegis, it still won the battle for him.Athrun wasn't FORCED to do anything, he could have escaped without blowing it up. He could have let go and gone on fighting him another way. Athrun had options Kira was pinned.
Weltall8000 Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - In GSD, Miriallia says, "I dumped him" and didn't really elaborate on anything else about their relationship.
lbwui Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - I donot said kira is better than shinn it is because i also dun no who is better . But u say shinn is better than kira u should take responsible for this . (Kira never goes on to beat Shinn.)i picked from other video comment but it make sense.
songlessnightingale Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - thank you Weltall8000. Sorry, but my knowledge of GS and GSD is very limited and thus I ask help from other fans such as yourself and Ibwui. thank you for your help.
Weltall8000 Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - I've been saying the entire time that Shinn is a better pilot than Kira.That battle is not what makes Shinn a better pilot than Kira.Shinn being a better pilot than Kira, make Shinn a better pilot than Kira.Using episode 34 as EVIDENCE supports that claim. As, if Shinn weren't a better pilot than Kira, he wouldn't be able to thoroughly route him like he did in episode 34.Since, in my world, we use evidence to support the things we say. So that it makes sense why we think what we do.
lbwui Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - welcome
lbwui Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - u said shinn is better than kira, it si just ur opinion. shinn beat kira doesnt mean he is better than kira.
Weltall8000 Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - If you beat me in a 1 on 1 basketball game, that doesn't give credence to you being a better basketball player than me?I beat you in a bike race, does that mean you are as good of a bicyclist as me?You beat me in a game of chess, does that seem likely that I am the better chess player?You score a 100% on a math test, I take the same math test and get a 25%, I must be as good at the math as you right?Think about it, does this make any sense to you?
lbwui Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - If you beat me in a 1 on 1 basketball game, that doesn't give credence to you being a better basketball player than me?I beat you in a bike race, does that mean you are as good of a bicyclist as me?You beat me in a game of chess, does that seem likely that I am the better chess player?You score a 100% on a math test, I take the same math test and get a 25%, I must be as good at the math as you right?It just 1 match does not mean all if i win many times that for sure
lbwui Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - take count of many other factor for example u slleping when test so u get 25% i gtg bybybe^.^ nice to meet you
ZzShouNeNzZ Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - wel chill out man >.> let these people believe what they wanna believe if you're the smarter person then stop arguing with them lol and of course shin is a better *pilot*, kira never went through military training like athrun and shin when he was younger, he just kinda got caught up in the war
ZzShouNeNzZ Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - and go watch gundam 00 people that's better
Weltall8000 Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - I am "chilled" <.
Weltall8000 Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - I'm waiting for the DVDs for OO to come out before I watch it. I'm looking forward to it. I'll be glad to see a new Gundam series without Marosawa's hands being anywhere near it.
ZzShouNeNzZ Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - you haven't seen it at all yet? oooh it's good i won't spoil it for you.
ZzShouNeNzZ Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - they're only going to keep commenting back trust me it's like a see saw in youtube, just be the better person and end it. you're only putting more fuel on the fire.
songlessnightingale Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - I agree with u there ZzShouNeNzZ
songlessnightingale Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - true very true
Wulfenbach Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - Don't think so highly of yourself, there is always someone who is better, sometime you will slip up and someone else takes the spot lights, its the facts of life.
snixsnipe Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - Kira clearly defeats Shinn in one of the earlier episodes when he does his typical "I fly by and disable you" move. You could argue he was still a newbie at that time, but it seems you ignore Kira's fight vs the Impulse (Kira was distracted and trying to help the Archangel?). Sorry, but Shinn never once beat Kira's STRIKE FREEDOM with his DESTINY gundam. I guess that DISPROVES your position. Destiny was far superior to Impulse SO WHY NOT?Because he couldn't beat Kira when he focused?
xIxJustxPwnedxYoux Says:
Oct 12, 2008 - saying something like "if athrun battery hadn't run out he would have killed kira." is straying from the facts also. Fact is athrun was forced to self destruct aegis, destroying both ms forcing a DRAW. if you're going to deny that then you are being a hypocrit.