Added: Aug 20, 2008
From: HonestReportingVideo
Duration: 3:29
Middle East and Media Expert Tom Gross Re-examines the original coverage of the famous incident in light of questions that emerged over the past seven years
Channel: News
Tags: al-dura bias dura durah honestreporting israel jews karsenty media news palestinians pen take take-a-pen zionism
Rating: 4.49 (231 ratings) Views: 35414' favoriteCount='120 Comments: 40
timufti3jieh Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - This proves conclusively what liars the Palestinian Arabs are. They have no concept whatsoever of what the word Truth means.
Snapper4298 Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - Proof yet again, as if it were needed, that Israel is not only the victim of terrorism, but also of left wing western propaganda.An excellent post, thank you.
IDF4ev Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - sir or mam, there is no proof? the second he said that they showed a man walking out of an ambulance smiling, watch the video again, they also darken slightly the rest of the scenery and show his face smiling
zplot77 Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - The video was shown in a public viewing in a French courtroom some time ago (well, 18 minutes of the original 27, since France 2 decided not to abide by a court order), but has not been released to the public. Today (Wednesday, February 27th) the judge should issue a ruling on Karsenty's case.
bigjelmapro Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - So give some examples where it hasn't ensured accuracy or promoted fairness.Plenty of other authors who use the term 'Londonistan' in reference to London and the UK overall being a hotbed of Islamic extremism. Pretty straightforward. But I guess you would want to continue to argue semantics.
TeachESL Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - Well, if someone shot him, it had to be the pals!
bigjelmapro Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - /watch?v=t_B1H-1opys@ 16:41.Nice try.
pretzelberg Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - At 2:02 we see two men smiling. So what?a) Neither look like the man being carried at 1:45b) Neither is seen walking out of an ambulance
pretzelberg Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - a) The film casts doubts on the version of events initially believed - yes.b) It does not provide grounds for making assumptions about an entre people, i.e. the Palestinians.c) Your comment proves conclusively that you are a racist.
jaakobou Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - @pretzelberg (and others), this is a 3 minutes video based on larger studies of events.'Three bullets and a dead child' - A remarkable documentary on the Palestinian Authority, Israel and a pivotal moment in the Israeli-Arab conflict.Film URL: tinyurl(dot)com(dash)2kakns
zo1dberg Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - Yep - damage is done. There is no way this video or others like it will spread like the original story did. MSM will yawn at this and the masses will continue to be angry at the wrong people because they will always be deceived.It's just not fair.
gobee53 Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - Everybody working for that French news agency should be lined up and given a firm kick in the Testicals or Ovaries depending on the case. Hell I'd pay to watch that.
happyfaithfulflower Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - Which lawyer or institution can sue France 2? How can this be a big trial with lots of international coverage? When will State of Israel and the Jewish People have a news station like CNN? Who owns CNN"? Why is their coverage so biased, and obviously so? Why is this tolerated? How can we help dissemninate the truth beyond sending this to everyone on our address list?
noamgreenboim Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - NEVER BELEIVE THE PALESTINIANS!!!
sooneryosaf Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - Two innocent reservist were butchered in Ramallah because of these lying bastards (as if they needed an excuse) and the Bush administration still wants to give them a damn terrorist state! Damn the Palestinian cause and damn the Bush administration for appeasing it!
khattak99 Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - Israel was built on false foundations on the blood of innocent Palestinians. it was a European who butchered you, not Palestinians. then why did you bring your dirty selves here. you will never see peace unless you end occupations of our land. even your holy scriptures warn that you will be routed.
jaakobou Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - @khattak99, Arabs have stolen the historical land of the Jewish people. Arabs have also kept Jews as dhimmies and caused some impressive strifes whenever an Arab leader "felt like becoming a better Muslim".Please don't mention holy scriptures, it only makes you look like a prejudiced bigot.
jaakobou Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - 'Three bullets and a dead child' - A remarkable documentary on the Palestinian Authority, Israel and a pivotal moment in the Israeli-Arab conflict.Film URL: tinyurl(dot)com(slash)2kakns
mostliberal Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - I remember when I watched this on TV in Israel.
thesidewinder39 Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - Turn on the TV. And watch the deaths of THE PALESTINIANS RIGHT NOW!!! THEY ARE DYING! ISRAEL IS KILLING THEM! I AM WATCHING IT RIGHT NOW!!
sohailakhan Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - Well, this vote has already been put on the Jewish Megaphone to be voted in favour of the Jews. Another proof that Jews are attempting to control the world through the media, money, and White House. While Palestinians civilians die along with the courageous Hamas fighters, fighting Israel with Sling Shots while Israelis fire back with US made lazer/Satellite guided missiles, bombs, while Helicopters using infra-red and Night Vision to pin point disarmed Palestinians.
Batsheva6022 Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - The day the Palestinians wake up and realize that their leaders have breastfed them since their early childhood with a culture of lies, martyrdom, murder of innocent civilians and hatred towards non-Mulims, that day, if they decide to rebel against their leaders and change: learn to respect the Jewish State of Israel, the United States of America and the Western world; that day, their lives would improve one hundred percent and they may see peace and prosperity.
Humeroniep Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - Yep, Jews own the media. Its true, which is why Hamas propaganda manages to finds its way into all major networks. Also, its true, Palestinians use sling shots, and the Katyusha rockets, and bombs, and people that decide to become walking explosives, and you know, all the stuff they use to target Israeli civilians.Can I ask you a personal question? Who was it that didn't love you enough? Was it a Jew? Do you need a hug sweetie?
lekuwait Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - Death to Israel..over 1 Million children killed by your missiles..you wonder why there is Suicide Bomber?! At this moment Gazah under missile attacks and air strikes. And in one day 60 Palestinians died as usual..and you still talking about what realy happend to Al-Dura!!!shame on you..if we r terrorist by the name of Jihad..you r terrorist by the name of USA..There will be no peace in the Middle East until we take back OUR LANDS
timufti3jieh Says:
Aug 20, 2008 - This conclusively shows, once and for all, what abject liars the Palestinians are. They wouldn't recognize the truth if it stood right in front of their faces.